The Gunn has jammed: DC’s reboot problem strikes again
by Eason Brohee

James Gunn and Peter Safran are stepping down from DC Studios, and once again, DC fans are left wondering what comes next. Effective December 1, former Marvel executive Jeremy Latcham will take over as president and chief creative officer, leaving the future of DC’s cinematic universe in new hands.
Gunn and Safran are expected to return to their creative work, including the upcoming “Superman: Man of Tomorrow”. And although their departure does not automatically mean another reboot is coming, the announcement raises a familiar question for DC fans: “how many times can this universe start over before audiences stop believing in it?”
DC has spent years trying to find its footing. First came Zack Snyder’s vision for the DC Extended Universe, a franchise that built a passionate following but struggled to maintain a consistent direction through years of studio interference, changing plans, and mixed audience reactions. Then came Gunn and Safran, tasked with rebuilding the brand around a new, interconnected universe.
Now, before that universe has had the chance to fully develop, another leadership change threatens to disrupt the very foundation they spent four years establishing. Technically, this is not yet a third reboot. But for fans who have watched DC repeatedly change course, it feels awfully familiar.
And that’s the problem. A cinematic universe isn’t built overnight. It takes years of character development, carefully planned storytelling, and the confidence that the people behind the scenes will allow their plans to unfold. For example, Marvel spent years building toward “The Avengers”, rewarding audiences who followed its heroes from their individual films into something larger. DC has repeatedly struggled to establish that same sense of continuity.
Every time the studio changes direction, audiences are asked to forget what came before, learn a new set of rules, and invest themselves all over again. Casual viewers are left confused about which movies connect, while longtime fans are forced to watch characters and storylines they care about get abandoned before reaching their potential. And behind every reboot are actors, writers, directors, and production teams whose work may suddenly become irrelevant to the larger franchise.
Now, to be fair, Gunn is far from an untalented filmmaker. His work on Marvel’s “Guardians of The Galaxy” trilogy helped turn a relatively obscure superhero team into household names. His filmography also includes “The Suicide Squad”, “Scooby-Doo”, and “Superman”, projects that demonstrate his ability to balance humor, emotion, strange characters, and genuine heart.
Personally, I believe projects like “Superman”, “Clayface”, “Blue-Beetle”, and “Creature Commandos” have each offered something worthwhile to DC audiences. But there is a difference between making great individual projects and building a great cinematic universe. A collection of good movies does not automatically create a compelling shared world, and I think that distinction is where the Gunn era has struggled.
The problem is not necessarily that Gunn chose the wrong characters or that every project needed to feature Batman, Superman, or Wonder Woman. In fact, some of his more unusual choices have been among the most interesting. “Clayface” is indeed a particularly bold direction for a comic book movie, while “Creature Commandos” shows that animation can contribute meaningfully to a larger universe.
But where is all of this going? What is the larger story connecting these characters, and why should audiences feel invested in the destination? I mean, the fact that DC is releasing a Clayface solo movie before establishing its new Batman in any kind of media besides his small cameo in “Creature Commandos” says something about the studio’s priorities. There is nothing inherently wrong with telling a story about a lesser-known character, but audiences need a reason to believe that these individual stories are building toward something meaningful.
Even “Lanterns”, which I consider a strong television series with compelling performances and excellent dialogue, illustrates my concern. It can be an entertaining mystery and a fascinating character study, but the Green Lantern mythos offers so much more than a grounded story on Earth. The Corps, the different Lantern colors, the cosmic threats, and the vast universe surrounding these characters are precisely what make Green Lantern special.
A show can succeed on its own terms while still leaving fans wanting more of what made the source material exciting in the first place. That is the distinction I keep coming back to: a good show is not automatically a great Green Lantern show, just as a good collection of DC projects is not automatically a great DC Universe.
Then there is the box office. Gunn’s tenure has produced real successes, including “Superman”, which earned more than $618 million worldwide. But the results have not been consistent. Its counterpart “Supergirl” earned approximately $126 million worldwide, a disappointing result for a major superhero release. And the shocking outlier? CLAYFACE! Superman drawing a crowd is always a guarantee, Supergirl not drawing and nearly as much was a bit of a shock, but “Clayface” being smack in the middle?
Well it just goes to show even more exactly how unpredictable this franchise has become. But, these outcomes are not proof that Gunn’s creative vision has failed, nor do they establish that box-office performance alone caused the leadership change. The studio has not publicly confirmed that the decision was made because of a lack of world-building. Still, the mixed results demonstrate the difficult position DC faces: it needs to build audience confidence while convincing people that this new universe is worth following.
And here is where the situation becomes especially frustrating. Gunn himself has acknowledged that running DC Studios was demanding, describing the corporate side of the job as difficult and expressing relief at returning to filmmaking. That is an important distinction. Being a great director and being the executive responsible for an entire entertainment franchise are two very different jobs. Gunn can be an excellent storyteller without necessarily being the person best suited to manage every aspect of DC’s long-term strategy.
His departure from the executive role does not erase his accomplishments, and it does not mean the studio has abandoned every project he helped establish. In fact, Gunn has indicated that his creative relationship with DC will continue.
But the timing is what makes this change so concerning. Gunn and Safran were brought in to provide DC with a unified creative direction. If their plans are now going to be reshaped by new leadership, fans have every reason to question how much confidence they should place in the next long-term roadmap. Will Jeremy Latcham preserve the foundations already laid? Will he redirect the franchise toward more familiar characters? Will the existing universe continue largely intact, or will DC eventually decide that another fresh start is necessary?
At the moment, those questions remain unanswered. What is clear is that the studio needs to communicate a consistent vision and give it enough time to succeed.

For me, the greatest missed opportunity is the possibility of a DC Universe that actually feels like a universe. I want to see Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, Aquaman, Martian Man-Hunter, The Flash, Green Lantern, and the rest of the Justice League inhabit a world where their stories matter to one another. I want the smaller projects to enrich the larger mythology, not simply exist beside it. I want Sinestro to become a genuine threat to the Green Lantern Corps, cosmic storylines to feel as important as Earth-bound mysteries, and the eventual formation of the Justice League to feel earned. I do not need every film to be an Avengers-level event, but I do want to feel that the studio has a destination in mind.
At this rate, a fully realized Justice League film feels less like an approaching milestone and more like something we could be waiting years to see.
And don’t get me wrong I love James Gunn. I believe he has made some fantastic films, and I believe DC still has the characters, mythology, and storytelling potential to compete with any franchise in Hollywood. But loving a filmmaker does not mean pretending every decision is perfect.
Gunn’s tenure has delivered some genuinely exciting projects, yet the larger connective tissue has not always been strong enough to make the universe feel cohesive. His departure from leadership is not the end of his career or necessarily the end of his DC stories, but it does mark another turning point for a franchise that desperately needs stability.
At the end of the day, DC does not need another dramatic announcement promising a brand-new beginning. It needs a plan, the patience to execute it, and the confidence to let its characters grow without constantly tearing down the world around them. The fans are here. The characters are here. The potential is absolutely here. What DC needs now is the consistency to make all of it matter.
James Gunn came to DC with the promise of a new creative era. Now, as he steps away from running the studio, the question is whether the universe he helped build can stand on its own.
Because when the Gunn keeps jamming, eventually, people will stop waiting for the next shot.



Great article